FM Studio Consulenza
FM Studio di Consulenza ProfessionaleDirection. Organisation. Results. Everything else is theory
ItalianoEnglish
Current affairs  ·  Training  ·  Topics  ·  Tools  ·  About the author

← All articles

A new shareholder in the company: the stake they receive depends on the value set before they come in

17 November 2026, 08:11

On 13 November, in Rome, Piccola Industria, the body within Confindustria (the Italian employers' federation) that represents smaller companies, presented its annual report: 61% of the companies surveyed would consider bringing in new shareholders, while 40.7% say they have already postponed, scaled back or abandoned at least one investment for lack of financial resources. For those thinking about it, the first question is a practical one: how much of the company has to be given up in exchange for the money the new shareholder brings?

Selling shares and increasing capital are two different operations

A newcomer can come in in two ways. If they buy shares from the existing shareholders, they pay them, and the money leaves the company and ends up in the pockets of those selling: the company has one more shareholder and not a single extra euro to invest. If instead they subscribe to a capital increase, they pay the money to the company, which uses it for the postponed investment; the existing shareholders keep their shares, which however now represent a smaller percentage of a larger company. To finance growth the second route is needed, and that is the one considered here.

In a capital increase the existing shareholders have a legal right to subscribe first to the new shares, in proportion to those they hold: for joint-stock companies this is laid down in Article 2441 of the Italian Civil Code, for limited liability companies in Article 2481-bis. For an outside shareholder to come in, therefore, the existing shareholders must waive that right. Alternatively, in a joint-stock company the shareholders' meeting can exclude it when the company's interest requires, with the vote of shareholders representing more than half of the capital; in a limited liability company new shares can be offered to third parties only if the articles of association allow it, and anyone who disagrees can withdraw, that is, leave the company and have their share paid out.

The stake is derived from the value before entry

The calculation takes the figure that investor and shareholders attribute to the company before the new money arrives, which is called the pre-money valuation. Adding the money paid in to that figure gives the post-money valuation, that is, what the company is worth immediately after the increase. The new shareholder's stake is the money they bring divided by the post-money value.

The typical mistake is to negotiate on the percentage and leave the valuation of the company implicit. When a sum is accepted in exchange for a certain stake, a pre-money valuation has already been set, without saying so, and, for the same sum paid in, every extra point given up lowers what the company is recognised as being worth. A serious negotiation starts from the starting value, which is supported by the plan for the following years: the turnover, margins, investments and cash that the money will make possible.

An example. An investor puts in €3 million and asks for 25%: this means that the company, after the increase, is worth €12 million, and before it was worth €9 million.

The money is split between share capital and share premium

In accounting terms the payment does not all go into share capital, which grows only by the nominal value of the new shares, usually small; the rest is the share premium, which enters equity as a reserve. Under Article 2431 of the Civil Code, written for joint-stock companies, the share premium cannot be distributed to shareholders until the legal reserve has reached one fifth of the share capital. Until then the share premium reserve cannot be used to pay dividends, either to the new shareholder or to the existing ones, and the money paid in remains available to the company.

The documents are prepared before meeting the investor

The basis for discussing the pre-money value is a three- or five-year plan setting out how the funds raised will be used and what they will return. Alongside the plan, the financial statements of recent years are needed, read as the investor will read them, with the financial debts and the commitments the liabilities do not show, such as leases and guarantees given. It is also worth deciding in advance what the owners are prepared to concede beyond the stake: a seat on the board of directors, a veto over certain decisions, the rules for the shareholder's exit after a few years. When the investor is an investment fund, it usually asks for these commitments to be written into a shareholders' agreement, the contract the shareholders sign among themselves alongside the articles of association.

A minority shareholder brings money with no maturity and no instalments, but not for free: their cost is the share of the company's future value that will be theirs. Bringing them in pays off for the existing shareholders when the part of the larger business they keep is worth more than the whole company they would have had without those funds.

This article was prompted by a news item published in Il Sole 24 Ore on 14 November 2026.

Written by Dr Flavio Marzani, founder of www.fmstudioconsulenza.it

Banks and debtOrganisation and people

Share this article with someone who needs it:LinkedInWhatsAppE-mail

Read also